The stack effect. Heated air rising through a closed house leaves the basement at slightly lower pressure than the ground, and that difference pulls soil gas through every opening in the foundation. Long, cold winters keep the pull running for months.
More detail
The colder it is outside, the bigger the temperature gap, and the harder the house draws on the soil. Frozen ground adds a second push: a frost cap over the yard limits how much soil gas can vent to open air, so more of it heads for the warm, unfrozen soil under your slab. Exhaust appliances stack on top of that, since dryers, range hoods, bath fans, and atmospheric furnaces all pull air out of the house and nudge indoor pressure lower still. That is why a January reading is the honest one here, and why a summer test tends to flatter the house. It is also why a working mitigation system matters most in exactly the months people keep the windows shut. See the best season to test.